What are the dominant political subcultures in Texas according to Elazar quizlet?

Given the prominence of slavery in its formation, a traditionalistic political culture, in Elazar’s argument, sees the government as necessary to maintaining the existing social order, the status quo. Only elites belong in the political enterprise, and as a result, new public policies will be advanced only if they reinforce the beliefs and interests of those in power.

 Elazar associates traditionalistic political culture with the southern portion of the United States, where it developed in the upper regions of Virginia and Kentucky before spreading to the Deep South and the Southwest. Like the individualistic culture, the traditionalistic culture believes in the importance of the individual. But instead of profiting from corporate ventures, settlers in traditionalistic states tied their economic fortunes to the necessity of slavery on plantations throughout the South.

When elected officials do not prioritize public policies that benefit them, those on the social and economic fringes of society can be plagued by poverty and pervasive health problems. For example, although the map below shows that poverty is a problem across the entire United States, the South has the highest incidence.

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the South also leads the nation in self-reported obesity, closely followed by the Midwest. These statistics present challenges for lawmakers not only in the short term but also in the long term because they must prioritize fiscal constraints in the face of a growing demand for services.

What are the dominant political subcultures in Texas according to Elazar quizlet?

While moralistic cultures expect and encourage political participation by all citizens, traditionalistic cultures are more likely to see it as a privilege reserved for only those who meet the qualifications. As a result, voter participation will generally be lower in a traditionalistic culture, and there will be more barriers to participation (e.g., a requirement to produce a photo ID at the voting booth).

Conservatives argue that these laws reduce or eliminate fraud on the part of voters, while liberals believe they disproportionally disenfranchise the poor and minorities and constitute a modern-day poll tax.

Finally, under a traditionalistic political culture, Elazar argues that party competition will tend to occur between factions within a dominant party. Historically, the Democratic Party dominated the political structure in the South before realignment during the civil rights era. Today, depending on the office being sought, the parties are more likely to compete for voters.

Abstract

A significant departure for the conception of a consensual national political culture is proposed by Daniel Elazar. According to Elazar, the national political culture is the synthesis of three major political subcultures (individualistic, moralistic, and traditionalistic) that are dominant in varying parts of the country. Using American National Election Studies (ANES) data, this study finds that the partisan differences in the political subcultures are becoming more pronounced, especially among whites. Elazar’s classification of political culture has become even more relevant to American politics in the twenty-first century than it was in the 1980s and 1990s. In particular, whites in traditionalistic states appear to be moving in a significantly more Republican direction than the nation as a whole. On the other end of the political spectrum, whites in states with moralistic subcultures tend to be becoming more Democratic. Relatedly, public policy preferences also vary considerably by subculture. Those in traditionalistic states are considerably more important on a number of non-economic issues, including gun control, abortion, and gay marriage than people in states with other dominant subcultures.

Recommended Citation

Fisher, Patrick (2016) "The Political Culture Gap: Daniel Elazar's Subculture in Contemporary American Politics," Journal of Political Science: Vol. 44 : No. 1 , Article 4.
Available at: https://digitalcommons.coastal.edu/jops/vol44/iss1/4

Access-controlled Item

If download is prevented click here for purchase options.

DOWNLOADS

Since April 15, 2020

COinS

Explaining Policy Differences Using Political Culture

    Political scientist Daniel Elazar identified political culture as one reason that different states enact different policies to deal with similar problems.  In fact, he identifies three political subcultures which combine to form the American political culture which he differentiates from the German political culture, the French political culture, or the Mexican political culture.  These political subcultures are:
 

Individualistic

  • The individualistic subculture relies on the marketplace.
  • Government's role is limited, primarily to keep the marketplace functioning.
  • Politicians' motives for running for office are based on material self-interests and to advance themselves professionally.
  • Bureaucracy is viewed negatively because it hinders patronage.
  • Corruption is tolerated because politics IS dirty.
  • Political competition is partisan.
  • Elections are oriented toward gaining office and do not deal with issues.
  • View originated in Middle Atlantic states, settled by German and English groups.
  • Migrated to lower Midwest, Missouri, and western states.
  • "Government should never get in the way!"

Moralistic

  • Opposite of individualistic.
  • Emphasizes the commonwealth.
  • Government advances the public interest and is a positive force in the lives of citizens.
  • Politics revolves around issues.
  • Politicians run for office to advance issues.
  • Corruption is not tolerated because government service is seen as public service.
  • Bureaucracy is viewed favorably as a way to achieve the public good.
  • It is a citizen's duty to participate in politics.
  • View was brought to the United States by the Puritans who settled in New England.
  • Transported across the upper Great Lakes into the Midwest to the Northwest.
  • Values reinforced by waves of Scandinavian and northern European groups.

Traditionalistic

  • Middle ground between individualistic and moralistic.
  • Ambivalent attitude toward the marketplace and the common good.
  • Government is maintain the existing social and economic hierarchy.
  • Politicians come from society's elite.
  • Politicians have a family obligation to govern.
  • Ordinary citizens are not expected to participate in politics or even to vote.
  • Politics is competition between rival factions within the elite rather than between class-based parties.
  • Bureaucracy is viewed with suspicion because it interferes with personal relationships.
  • View was brought to the United States by people who settled the southern colonies.
  • Built a plantation-centered agricultural system.
  • Descendants moved westward through the southern and southwestern states.
What are the dominant political subcultures in Texas according to Elazar quizlet?
Political Culture in Texas

    According to Elazar, Texas's political culture is a combination of traditionalistic and individualistic elements.  The traditionalistic aspects of state politics are exemplified by the long history of one-party dominance in state politics, the low level of voter turnout, and social and economic conservatism.  The individualistic nature of state politics can be seen in the support for private business, opposition to big government, and faith in individual initiative.

Is Change Possible?

    These subcultures were derived from analyzing settlement and migration patterns that were largely completed by the early 20th Century.  Is it possible for migrations that occurred after the 1950s to have affected the political subculture of the states?  For example, what has been the impact of large numbers of northern retirees moving to a traditionalistic state like Florida?  Has the influx of northerners affected Texas politics or do the new immigrants adapt to the old political subculture?  We could better understand the impact of population growth on political culture by studying the politics of a area like Amarillo or specifically southwest Amarillo.

This discussion is drawn from the following sources:
    Gray, Virginia. 1999. "The Socioeconomic and Political Context of States." In Politics in the American States: A Comparative Analysis, 7th ed., Virginia Gray, Russell L. Hanson, and Herbert Jacob, eds. Washington, DC: CQ Press.
    Tannahill, Neal. 2000. Texas Government: Policy and Politics, 6th ed. New York: Longman.
    My brain.

Back to American State and Local Government Page
Back to Course Page Central

What political cultures does Elazar claim operates in Texas?

Elazar's Theory claims that Texas is a mixture of traditional and individualistic political cultures. As a result, the voter turnout in Texas is lower than most other American states, with the argument that Texans view political participation as an economic perk versus the value of contributing to society.

What is the dominant political culture in Texas?

For about a hundred years, from after Reconstruction until the 1990s, the Democratic Party dominated Texas politics. In a reversal of alignments, since the late 1960s the Republican Party has grown more prominent. By the 1990s, it became the state's dominant political party and remains so to this day.

What is the dominant political culture among Texans quizlet?

* texas is classified as having a traditionalistic individualistic political culture. * classical liberalism, social conservatism, and populism are three primary ideological influences of Texas culture.

How does Mr Elazar define political culture quizlet?

According to Elazar, Texas can be described as traditionalistic and individualistic. Political culture is a term used to describe. the broadly shared values and beliefs about government.

What is the dominant political culture of voters in Texas quizlet?

Texas political culture can best be characterized as individualistic and traditional. Texas is a low-tax state with distrust for large government programs. Business plays a major role in defining the political culture of the state.

What two political cultures are prominent in Texas quizlet?

The political culture of Texas is dominated by the individualistic and traditionalistic subcultures. - The individualistic culture is rooted in the search for individual opportunity of the state's early settlers and is reflected in its constitutionally weak government and low spending on public programs.